So you think you can do better?

I love my readers. Well, not the mean ones who post snide reviews on Amazon, obviously, but the ones who enjoy the books and are kind enough to let me know. Funny thing this, I've read voraciously for years, hero-worship more than one household name writer, but I've never once got in touch with any of them to tell them how much I've enjoyed a book, or to thank them for their work.

Which makes me now a bit ashamed of myself, as though for the same number of years I've been going to parties and to friends' houses for dinner without ever bothering with a thank you note. Because lots of people write to thank me and I can't tell you how lovely it is to get these cheery little notes in my inbox.

I can't say they make it all worthwhile, because it would be more than worthwhile anyway, but they certainly are the icing on the cake.

My favourite reader of the moment, though, is without doubt Carolyn from Texas who, whilst enjoying Awakening, felt the ending didn't quite hit the note she was looking for. So, and I'm sure only an American reader would think of doing this, she tore out the last ten pages, re-wrote it and sent it back to me.

And you know what - her version wasn't bad.

Spoiler alert - don't read on if you haven't yet (and might one day) finished Awakening.

Carolyn felt the ending didn't quite hit the romantic note she'd been hoping for. Not enough for this reader that heroine Clara has battled venomous snakes, resurrected corpses and saved the man she loves from a flesh dissolving end. She needed plucky Clara to be rewarded with a snog.

So in the new version she is. And for all those of you who found the ending of Awakening just that little lacking in warmth, here is Carolyn's re-write of pg 390.

Somehow, we'd moved closer. I could smell the wool of Matt's jacket, warm in the sunshine, his skin, his hair.

'What about your girlfriend, Matt?' I asked.

'Erstwhile girlfriend,' he replied, covering my lips with his. It was a slow, deeply satisfying kiss. Too soon, he pulled back and looked at me. With the barest touch, he laid his fingertips alongside the scar on my face.

'Are you OK?,' he asked.

Actually, Carolyn isn't alone. A lot of readers expressed their disappointment that the romances in both Awakening and Blood Harvest weren't tied up a little more neatly.  With Blood Harvest, in particular, I had an alternative ending in mind, much warmer and sexier, and had even written three quarters of it in my head. But when it came to it, in both books, the events leading up to the final pages were just too grim to tie either story up with a twee happy ending.

The other problem with having your characters ride off into the sunset, is that it's then so much harder to bring them back for subsequent books. If characters achieve a happy ending, I like to leave them there. On the other hand, if the events are resolved but not the relationships, there is scope to revisit.

I've just taken Evi Oliver out of her box, dusted her off and am trying her out for a leading role in book five. I wasn't too keen on Evi, all the time I was writing Blood Harvest. I found her a bit unwieldy, less interesting that my previous two lead females. In all fairness to her, though, she's bringing book five to life. Will she have her happy ending in Book Five? I suspect not, anymore than Lacey (whom you have yet to meet) will.

Book four is still with She Who Is About To Become A Vision In White and we've just heard that James Patterson has stolen my preferred title for it: Tick Tock. Honestly, that man! So, the race is on to find a new title for a book that is a modern take on the Jack the Ripper case before the cover design has to be agreed. Usually, that's sometime in … June! Ooops, my schedule is slipping.

By the way, if anyone fancies rewriting the endings of any of my books, feel free! I'll post the best ones here on the website.

4 comments for “So you think you can do better? ”

  1. Posted 15 July 2010 at 11:18:15

    Well you responded to me, which wasmuch appreciated. And I skipped the middle bit of this post as I have only just started 'Awakening' - darned spoilers!

  2. Gravatar of Kathy BernettKathy Bernett
    Posted 15 August 2010 at 18:32:32

    Unlike Carolyn from Texas who wanted a happier ending for Awakening, my little issue is with the ending of Blood Harvest, which I found quite confusing. I didn't expect Harry & Evi to "snog", as you Brits put it, at the end, but I was very confused as to why Harry left town. I went back several times to reread, counted off the fact that all the good people were alive, the kids were safe & the baddies got their just deserts, but I still could not understand why Harry zoomed out of town. Would you mind explaining a little about why you ended the book this way & maybe let us in on the alternative ending that you didn't use? I'm glad to hear that Evi will be returning because I did like the character. Can't wait for "Book Four" whatever its title turns out to be.
    Kathy from Michigan

  3. Gravatar of LorraineLorraine
    Posted 11 October 2010 at 22:52:04

    I have read all 3 of your books in the last week and i enjoyed them all too much no housework or cooking was done till they were read............... I am an avid reader( not a great writer myself) but its a long long time since i enjoyed a book so much especially sacrafice, it was well researched and very very clever I cant wait for ur next book ...roll on 2011 ..

  4. Gravatar of SJ SJ
    Posted 18 October 2010 at 13:40:05

    First of all, so sorry, Kathy, not to reply to you before now. The software on the website isn't quite working as it should, so new posts aren't always brought to my attention.

    My thinking with Harry was that his faith had had a severe shake. I don't think he's lost his belief in God, just that, for the present, he doesn't feel able to continue being a minister. Harry is the sort of man who would need to feel 100% conviction in order to lead the faith of others. He's leaving town because Evi will no longer have anything to do with him and getting away seems like the best way of getting over a) recent events and b) her.

    He'll be coming back though, possibly in book 6 and maybe, via a cameo appearance, in book 5.

    I have to admit, though, I'm getting grief, not just from readers but even from editors on both sides of the atlantic (and Germany) on the subject of my rather grim endings. I can see I'm going to have to lighten up a bit.

    Lorraine, nice to hear from you. Glad you enjoyed Sacrifice. I'm just doing copy edits on book 4, NOW YOU SEE ME, and expect it to go into production any time now.

Post a comment